I recently received this comment on a portrait that I took :
“But why did you cut off the top of the head ???”
And it sounded more like a criticism than a question.
To some people it may look weird or unpleasant, but to me it looks just fine, especially because it allows to place the eyes somewhere nearby the 1/3 of the frame. But while I like to cut off the forehead, I avoid cutting off in the middle of the chin or of the hand. So are there any rules to crop a portrait ?
Let’s make it clear that there are no so called rules but only recommendations or guidelines, you can follow them if you are unsure how to crop, and if you already have an good intuition just follow it. In general the guidelines are :
– Do not cut on a joint like the knee or the elbow.
– Hands are fully in the picture or not at all.
The picture below is a revisited Vitruvian Man from Leornardo Da Vinci, I have highlighted in green the area where it is common to cut off, and in red where it is not recommended.